The CPL have just let me know that they will be using default Painkiller for the Winter event and not Battle Out of Hell, due to the delay that was announced yesterday. They also said that there may be some late changes to the version used in the event, as there is a 1.4 update due sometime soon.
Aside from that, they also let it known that they will be using the tweaked version of DM_Fallen2; DM_Fallen2te.
Holy fuck! 🙂
I think one possible spawn weapon solution would be to change the secondary fire of the painkiller to be something more along the lines of a boomstick. Possibly even sharing ammo with the shotgun, it would have a medium spread, moderate to fast fire rate, medium to low damage. You’d be able to get kills with it, but it’d take a while or the assistance of a team mate. This may be more appropriate for 1v1 or TDM modes than FFA (where the stake spawn kinda makes FFA into a pseudo clan arena imo).
Nice read Bnew, it brings lots of interesting ideas, and made me want to answer it. There are my thoughts :
Yep, I think a spawn weapon should really have minimal damage. The point is to have well balanced map where someone respawning will be able to pick weapons and armor in the weakest zone of the map, but someone spawning with a powerful weapon is not a good idea imo, even if it’s hard to hit with it (there will always be that lucky shot at first, and slowly people will master the stake gun better and better and most people will be able to make a come back easily with the spawn weapon although the other guy has the map in hand).
I don’t think the shotgun is a good choice either, and thus as you say, any weapon that is chosen as the spawn weapon should be weakened. It’s the well-known problem of vQ3, start the game, meet your opponent, win a close fight while having only a few health points left, and you’re screwed, cause he respawns with 120 health and a powerful machinegun. Although you won the fight, you lost the map.
I don’t really agree with that. Normally you hear a spawn and you know where you are (and most likely in some time you’ll known where the spawn are so you should be able to find the guy in an instant, moreover if he spawns just behind you). By the time he realize where he is you should be able to kill him first. Of course there is a really thin chance he will spawn behind you with you right in his crosshair – but this would be really unlucky, and you’re supposed after some time to be able to anticipate his spawn and prevent that. That’s what I think, at least. 🙂
As I said, my point is that a spawning player should have to rely on the weakest part of the map rather than on spawning weapons. Maps must be well-designed so that someone having lost control of the map still has a zone where he can stack on weak armors and strong weapons, to be able to attack and regain control of the strong zone of the map. Remember that we’re not only talking about duel, but also about TDM. 4 players with a pretty strong spawnweapon can do lots of harm on a synchronized rush, especially when the opposite team is spreading in the map trying to secure more than one zone.
This is not fair, spawning players should have to secure the weakest zones of the maps and pick weapons and armor there to then be able to rush and secure a better zone.
Partly agreed. 🙂
The randomness of the shotgun is something very annoying to me – to take an example, my favorite shotgun is in CPMA. It always hits the same way, and is very reliable. On the other hand, it still is a pure close-combat weapon – above a certain distance, it’s useless, or just a finishing weapon.
This is an interesting idea. I think chaingun was coupled with RL to prevent it from the annoying situation you have in vQ3 – pick a RL, meet someone that just spawned with MG but is way too far to be hit with RL, and you’re screwed. But all in all it remains the same : the chaingun will easily overcome RL at long range fights, meaning people at ease with chaingun will flee when in close combat and try to make it a chaingun-only fight, and the knockback of the chaingun will help that by preventing his opponent from rushing him – the better people will handle chaingun, the worse it’ll be.
And the unability to quickly attain our highest speed (as with circle strafe jump in Q3 for example) won’t help that. This could lead to annoying “flee & hit from long range” games.
Yep, I totally agree with you on that.
I partly agree with you. That said I think a good experience of TP, or at least a good knowledge of how it should work, is enough to see whether a map should be good or not. But the best way to know is always to playtest it seriously, for sure.
This is a good thought to me, except for one thing : you cannot prevent somebody from having a timer next to his screen. For example, I have a friend that used to own at CPMA 1on1, and you might know that they removed the timer in CPMA 1on1 (it displays as 01:xx, 02:xx, etc) while they kept it in TDM.
But he used to have a timer next to his screen, cause he knew other people used those as well, and he didn’t want to have a disadvantage because of it. You might prevent people from using their own timers in LAN, but online it’ll be impossible, and everyone will end up using them to play on the same ground.
Once again, I agree.
I don’t want QW movements, I like to think of PK as something new that brings new ideas, something more than a mere copy, although it is firmly inspired from games like QW – and that’s a good thing for sure. 🙂
I won’t comment too much on your propositions. They seem quite good, but I’d be happy with the current system, with just the addition of an initial jump to gain speed quickly that would require skill – just as circle strafing in vQ3/CPMA.
There should also be the possibility to keep your speed in stairs – might be just me but atm I lose lots of speed when I try to climb stairs and after several tries can’t succeed in doing better.
//Concerning weapon balance
Id say make the stake gun a pickup weapon, reduce its damage to under a 100, and make it an instant hit or nearly instant hit projectile with the current or maybe slighty faster reload rate, any delay combined with PK’s insane movement speed makes hitting a stake more luck than skill, speed the projectile up!
power up the shotgun slighty and make it the new spawn weapon
weaken the chaingun so that the lg is more powerful in comparision, add knockback to lg, and remove it from cg, there is no point to having a powerful cg and lg at close range, make chaingun used purely for longer range finishing off, and lg for close/medium ranges but make the beam quite short, in that way you would see players lg at close to medium ranges but from medium to long they might pull out cg instead, think about it, whats the point of 2 stong fast firing instant hit weapons? since we are already limited in the amount of useful guns lets rather let the 2 guns perform entirely differently from each other.
//Concerning ingame timer
Add it! One might say it reduces strat, i tend to disagree, with correctly balanced maps it allows both players to snag armour/megahealths while not in control, and there is a skill to timing, not everyone can do it when playing a very good opponent, i think especially in a super fast game like pk a timer would help alot since the player in control can just get from one armour to the next in a matter of seconds leaving the other player at a somewhat disadvantage, however if the other player knew when the item was coming this would help him at least stand a chance at his opponent who is probably got more armour than him anyway even if he gets the powerup…
greywolve : in no way is there going to be a rail in PK. 🙂
The delay with the stakegun’s projectile was implemented to make it a skill demanding weapon, justifying its high damage, while a railgun-like instant hit weapon demands none (point at your target, click, 100 damages, while it takes so much more skill to predict and hit a full rocket or hit several ammos with any other weapon to do as much damage).
I’m glad the devs did that, and I hope they’ll stick to their decision.
yeah i agree with that air movement thing, cos sometimes when i jump from a ledge and want to look back it sucks (imagine sacred in the 2nd level in the big teleport room that u want to jump from the ledge and look to the entrance which is opposite to teleport, i sometimes jump, move the mice, and come up again to the ledge, and that really annoys me)
Reminds me of the Brett Favre Commercials that played here in the States around the Superbowl time. “I’d’ve double bagged it”
i think the weapon balance is kinda crap..
the weapons itsealf offer lots of potential, but the very powerful chaingun/rocket launcher combination offers to much damage..
i would take some power away from the chaingun…
a weakend shotgun as the starting weapon sounds great, cuz the stake gun seems to offer way too much power when ppl have finally learned to master it, which is an issue that wont last too long..
No, they really shouldn’t make the shotgun weaker and making it the standard spawning weapon. The shotgun is my fav. gun and i don’t want it to become a weak spawning weapon. I agree that a shotgun would fit nice as a spawn weapon, but i really don’t want them to make the shotgun almost useless compared to the other weapons.
As a board newbie, I feel it’s polite to explain where I’m coming from first.
I’m aware Brian has said that he want’s to recreate a full on hardcore 1-on-1 experience, which I’m all for. I love quakeworld duels. At the same time I also love TDM. There is nothing about Quake that I do not like. I’ll play any deathmatch game for a laugh, but I will of course always revert to games in this order: Quake 3, UT2003, UT2004, Quake 2, CS, CPMA, QW.
Preference of game types in descending order without going in to too much depth?
utassault,1fctf,ctf,clan arena,tdm,2v2,1on1
Obviously to try and be impartial given I’m totally for the 1on1 experience, I’d suggest that a variant of UTAssault be considered. Even if this is simply a checkpoint system without anything too fancy ala UT (which might be nice later for atmospheric reasons and bringing the game to life of course). I say this because such a mode could be fun. There are people out there who like team based games and whilst as brian says there are more team based games out there, a simple game like this would just be in the spirit of quake. People love mods, the more mods there are, the more a community grows. Some people, understandably want a fun game and it should always be beared in mind that this is exactly where we started. Newbies want games with good graphics. The first bite is with the eye as they say 😉 Eventually what would happen is you’d have all the competetive players from all different types of games congregating together, and sooner or later they’re going to have to play a 1on1.. after all, what’s a DM player doing in the game without pride and honour eh? 😉
To cut it short, for anyone skimming this post the game would essentially be this: team deathmatch with checkpoints for people who can’t stand the waiting around during games to keep them playing.
As an after thought, you’d have health, weapons and powerups available – to ensure that teams had to whore items whilst keeping an objective in mind and having one guy at least constantly on the move, meaning if both teams were playing aggressively, then each player would still have to be a great 1on1 player to truly dominate the map.
Much like the ‘push’ mode in DOD, you could have just a single checkpoint so that you can guarantee a good old fight at any time. To make sure you can guarantee this, set a delay on the time it takes for the spawn point to change, or indeed set an area – so that once a checkpoint comes in to a players view (ala the old find head routine in QC to make it simple) they must hold the area(randomly generated with the arrow at the top still?) whilst on their toes ensuring no player ever got a moments rest.
Thus this game can only work if players revert to the old ways of TDM and are able to handle the pace of a checkpoint system thrown in aswell.
Obviously clan arena would still be the ultimate test of who’s the better player when given godlike status – which I think we can agree, is fun. Or perhaps even a last man standing mode with the original.
So I say that other game modes should be taken in to account given the following reasons:
A totally customisable game gives us the opportunity to try everything out. Although the developers intentions are noble, if we’re to keep great gameplay alive then we need to have some kinda open mindedness to other modes aswell. It’s a lot of work for the painkiller team, but something I’m sure they’ll happily undertake as a hobby more than a project after the 1on1 is sorted which as we all know, is the foundation for ANY kinda hardcore game.
So I’d say by having this mode put in, not only would we see the “greatest of all time gamers” emerge, but that we’d also see other games considering that painkiller MIGHT be the way forward and eventually we’ll find balance in a sense that is truly competetive meaning nobody could ever say “Your game is shit” ever again. If so.. “1on1 time.. both games.. ya scared?”
a gamer has to know when to be fast and when to go slow after all, as quakeworld clearly shows us with its gameplay that makes you REALLY appreciate the chance to stand still and think about what you’ve done today.
Sorry, but people are still gonna turn around and say ‘its too fast for me’ if you strive to stay too true to the original concept – regardless of whether finances are important – meaning it’s a game which will still only cater for an audience of quakeworlds size – but a little bit of open-ness and you end up with the environment we’re used to. “Globalnet servers are shite! Good place to start though..”. If you step on to a server, you’d better be playing your best to perform if you dont wanna get laughed at. Does it sound like I have a disturbing desire to be the new PK Mafia?
“All your frags are belong to me. Stand the fuck still n00b.”
Which, if anyone happens to be reading this who is a CS player and disagrees with an abusive attitude in games.. it’s an unwritten rule in QW that if you dont want to get abuse, you play well and just keep your chat to a minimum. or you bugger off elsewhere. occasionally people ARE nice and apologise for being wankers.. but rarely and quite right too. They’re there to win the game and have fun. Foul language is a part of that. If quake were real, would you sit there and say ‘well played old chap’ ? No. Not unless you were xaero in Q3. Which of course explains our entire attitude that until you get to the top, you dont deserve as much respect and you can still be shouted at. At the end of it all, you shout a lot, you have a game and chances are you’ve made a good friend by the end of it. Hence the importance of saying ‘gg’ or if you must remain abusive in the name of comedy “Well you fucking cunt, that’s me told.” If you dont, you’re just a sore loser who doesn’t deserve to be playing quake in the first place. Bloody full of the milk of human kindness you lot 😛
Sorry to drone on a bit, first post, lots of thoughts and I dont see them repeated here yet. I thought the mentality was an important thing if you really want to create a new quake 🙂
– Steve
As a board newbie, I feel it’s polite to explain where I’m coming from first.
I’m aware Brian has said that he want’s to recreate a full on hardcore 1-on-1 experience, which I’m all for. I love quakeworld duels. At the same time I also love TDM. There is nothing about Quake that I do not like. I’ll play any deathmatch game for a laugh, but I will of course always revert to games in this order: Quake 3, UT2003, UT2004, Quake 2, CS, CPMA, QW.
Preference of game types in descending order without going in to too much depth?
utassault,1fctf,ctf,clan arena,tdm,2v2,1on1
Obviously to try and be impartial given I’m totally for the 1on1 experience, I’d suggest that a variant of UTAssault be considered. Even if this is simply a checkpoint system without anything too fancy ala UT (which might be nice later for atmospheric reasons and bringing the game to life of course). I say this because such a mode could be fun. There are people out there who like team based games and whilst as brian says there are more team based games out there, a simple game like this would just be in the spirit of quake. People love mods, the more mods there are, the more a community grows. Some people, understandably want a fun game and it should always be beared in mind that this is exactly where we started. Newbies want games with good graphics. The first bite is with the eye as they say 😉 Eventually what would happen is you’d have all the competetive players from all different types of games congregating together, and sooner or later they’re going to have to play a 1on1.. after all, what’s a DM player doing in the game without pride and honour eh? 😉
To cut it short, for anyone skimming this post the game would essentially be this: team deathmatch with checkpoints for people who can’t stand the waiting around during games to keep them playing.
As an after thought, you’d have health, weapons and powerups available – to ensure that teams had to whore items whilst keeping an objective in mind and having one guy at least constantly on the move, meaning if both teams were playing aggressively, then each player would still have to be a great 1on1 player to truly dominate the map.
Much like the ‘push’ mode in DOD, you could have just a single checkpoint so that you can guarantee a good old fight at any time. To make sure you can guarantee this, set a delay on the time it takes for the spawn point to change, or indeed set an area – so that once a checkpoint comes in to a players view (ala the old find head routine in QC to make it simple) they must hold the area(randomly generated with the arrow at the top still?) whilst on their toes ensuring no player ever got a moments rest.
Thus this game can only work if players revert to the old ways of TDM and are able to handle the pace of a checkpoint system thrown in aswell.
Obviously clan arena would still be the ultimate test of who’s the better player when given godlike status – which I think we can agree, is fun. Or perhaps even a last man standing mode with the original.
So I say that other game modes should be taken in to account given the following reasons:
A totally customisable game gives us the opportunity to try everything out. Although the developers intentions are noble, if we’re to keep great gameplay alive then we need to have some kinda open mindedness to other modes aswell. It’s a lot of work for the painkiller team, but something I’m sure they’ll happily undertake as a hobby more than a project after the 1on1 is sorted which as we all know, is the foundation for ANY kinda hardcore game.
So I’d say by having this mode put in, not only would we see the “greatest of all time gamers” emerge, but that we’d also see other games considering that painkiller MIGHT be the way forward and eventually we’ll find balance in a sense that is truly competetive meaning nobody could ever say “Your game is shit” ever again. If so.. “1on1 time.. both games.. ya scared?”
a gamer has to know when to be fast and when to go slow after all, as quakeworld clearly shows us with its gameplay that makes you REALLY appreciate the chance to stand still and think about what you’ve done today.
Sorry, but people are still gonna turn around and say ‘its too fast for me’ if you strive to stay too true to the original concept – regardless of whether finances are important – meaning it’s a game which will still only cater for an audience of quakeworlds size – but a little bit of open-ness and you end up with the environment we’re used to. “Globalnet servers are shite! Good place to start though..”. If you step on to a server, you’d better be playing your best to perform if you dont wanna get laughed at. Does it sound like I have a disturbing desire to be the new PK Mafia?
“All your frags are belong to me. Stand the fuck still n00b.”
Which, if anyone happens to be reading this who is a CS player and disagrees with an abusive attitude in games.. it’s an unwritten rule in QW that if you dont want to get abuse, you play well and just keep your chat to a minimum. or you bugger off elsewhere. occasionally people ARE nice and apologise for being wankers.. but rarely and quite right too. They’re there to win the game and have fun. Foul language is a part of that. If quake were real, would you sit there and say ‘well played old chap’ ? No. Not unless you were xaero in Q3. Which of course explains our entire attitude that until you get to the top, you dont deserve as much respect and you can still be shouted at. At the end of it all, you shout a lot, you have a game and chances are you’ve made a good friend by the end of it. Hence the importance of saying ‘gg’ or if you must remain abusive in the name of comedy “Well you fucking cunt, that’s me told.” If you dont, you’re just a sore loser who doesn’t deserve to be playing quake in the first place. Bloody full of the milk of human kindness you lot 😛
Sorry to drone on a bit, first post, lots of thoughts and I dont see them repeated here yet. I thought the mentality was an important thing if you really want to create a new quake 🙂
– Steve
er, it did a double post when I hit F5. apologese for that.. please delete.
– Steve
just my personal opinion, I won’t even try too hard to justify it : if you try and create the perfect gameplay it will most likely have the lesser community.
A great gameplay means the game is hard to master, you have a interest in playing it hardcore so that you don’t get bored of it and give it up after 6 months or less. This is what has kept qw alive for so long (there is still more than one league going on with many divisions and clans in them).
Thing is, most people will give up on a really good gameplay because they won’t be able to simply sit in a corner and easily make some frags (q3 style), they’ll have to try hard and learn the keys of the game, improve their skills, get owned several times before they get a result, and most people can’t be arsed with trying that hard.
So most players will always end up playing newbiish games likes CS and other so-called realistic shooters, beeing happy with just the random easy frags they get, not trying to look for anything better than that.
A good game needs to not have stupid weapons like railgun which can easily do lots of damage whilst other weapons demand much more skill for the same damage if not less damage, and that’s why most people won’t bother playing a good FPS.
You can’t have both a big community and a really good game, if you try to mix both you’ll end up with something half-decent like vQ3.
nice to see fallen2te there
am i the only one here whi dont like new fallen? 😛
I hate all fallen2 maps.. But te is better..
Agree with CLains, bot fallen2 maps are bad and a sort of imbalanced but the “tournament edition” is way better than the original fallen2 map.
Also good that they won’t use BooH @ CPL Winter. Not much time left to accomodate to the game.
wtf ? why….
I hate both maps, but I think original fallen2 is a map with some good aspects, in fact, you must be really good player to be good on the fallen2. fallen2te is nothing more then piece of junk, this map totally sux for me.
and about BooH: when they play on the LAN, the netcode doesn’t matter. so it can be original PK, or BooH… the only reason is if PCF planning changes in weapons system in MP and adding new maps etc.
When do we get the 1.4 patch?
i know people who know people who has 1.4 already :))
By sevenflow
am i the only one here whi dont like new fallen? 😛
no, i dont like this map too… ;s
Fallen 2 is my fav map…
shaft is to strong…
a little nerf to shaft and fallen2te will be good :>
original fallen2 without sa and with 2 mh is rofl :>
why fallen2te ?? why ??
jup jup whine whine
Davaite parni !!
naeboshim burzhuev v PK !!)
best demos was uploaded in http://www.gotfrag.com
:>
Upload the demos to our demo page someone? :>
as long as there is no dm_psycho that map sucks so extremely much!!
there is psycho at cpl…
i like your website very much but please do get us more information about it